When a Bondsman Surrenders a Defendant
In North Carolina, a surety can surrender a defendant to the sheriff before or after a breach of the bond. If the surrender is before any breach and the defendant did nothing listed in G.S. 58-71-20, the full premium must be returned within 72 hours. If the defendant missed a payment, moved without notice, hid, left the state, violated a court order or lied on the application, the bondsman can surrender without a refund.
- A bondsman can surrender a defendant to the sheriff and be released from the bond; the defendant goes back into custody.
- Surrender before any breach, for no listed reason, requires a full premium refund within 72 hours.
- Seven listed reasons, including a missed payment, an unreported move or leaving the state, allow surrender with no refund.
- After surrender, a judicial official decides whether the defendant can be released again and on what conditions.
When a bondsman posts a bond, they take on the risk of paying the full amount if the defendant does not appear. North Carolina gives them a way out of that risk: they can return the defendant to the sheriff. This is called a surrender, and it is the most common reason a person who was bailed out ends up back in custody without a new charge.
When can a bondsman surrender a defendant?
The law treats surrender differently depending on whether the bond has been breached (usually by a missed court date).
Before any breach. Under G.S. 58-71-20, at any time before there has been a breach, the surety may surrender the defendant to the sheriff of the county where the defendant is bonded to appear, or the sheriff where the defendant was bonded. After that surrender, G.S. 15A-540(a) says the clerk must exonerate (release) the surety from the bond when the surety applies.
After a breach. Under G.S. 15A-540(b), after a breach the surety may arrest the defendant and surrender them to the sheriff, or, if the defendant is already in a sheriff's custody, surrender them by appearing in person and telling the sheriff. The surety must give the sheriff a copy of the bond, forfeiture, or release order. The sheriff gives the surety a receipt, and that receipt is one of the listed grounds for setting aside a forfeiture.
G.S. 58-71-30 adds that, for the purpose of surrender, a surety may arrest the defendant before forfeiture, or may ask any judicial officer to order the arrest by written authority endorsed on a certified copy of the bond. The surety may use licensed bondsmen or runners to help.
When does the bondsman have to refund the premium?
This is the question families care about most. Under G.S. 58-71-20, if the surety surrenders the defendant before a breach, the full premium must be returned within 72 hours after the surrender, unless the defendant did any of the following:
- Willfully failed to pay the premium, or willfully missed a payment under the written payment agreement.
- Changed address without notifying the surety before the change.
- Physically hid from the surety.
- Left the State without the surety's permission.
- Violated any order of the court.
- Failed to disclose, or gave false information about, any failure to appear, any felony conviction in the past 10 years, or any pending charges in any state or federal court.
- Knowingly gave incorrect identification, or used a false name or alias.
If any of those apply, the bondsman can surrender without refunding. In other words, a bondsman who simply changes their mind, with the defendant doing everything right, has to give the premium back.
What happens to the defendant after surrender?
The defendant is back in the sheriff's custody. After a surrender following a breach, G.S. 15A-540(c) requires the sheriff to take the defendant before a judicial official without unnecessary delay, with a copy of the bond and the receipt. The official then decides whether the defendant is again entitled to release and, if so, on what conditions. If the surrender follows a missed court date, expect higher conditions; see what happens if you miss court on bond.
The defendant may be able to post a new bond, including through a different surety. Being surrendered is something the next bondsman will ask about.
What can't a bondsman do during a surrender?
G.S. 58-71-95 bars every bondsman and runner from impersonating a law-enforcement officer, and from falsely claiming to be connected with any federal, state, or local government agency. A bondsman also cannot pay law-enforcement officers, directly or indirectly, to arrest a defendant who has caused or will cause a forfeiture. If you see conduct like this, see how to file a complaint about a bail bondsman.
Why bondsmen surrender people
Common real-world triggers include:
- A missed court date.
- Missed payments on the premium plan.
- Not answering calls or missing required check-ins.
- A new arrest, which raises the risk on the existing bond. See arrested again while on bond.
- A co-signer withdrawing support or reporting that the defendant plans to leave.
- Learning about prior failures to appear or pending charges that were not disclosed.
How to avoid being surrendered
- Make every court date and every scheduled check-in.
- Pay on the written schedule. If you will be late, call before the due date.
- Tell the bondsman before you move, and get written permission before leaving North Carolina.
- Follow every condition in your release order.
- Answer the application honestly about prior failures to appear, convictions, and pending charges.
What about collateral after a surrender?
A surrender ends the surety's liability once the bond is exonerated. Under G.S. 58-71-95(5), collateral must be returned within 15 days after final termination of liability on the bond. If the surrender followed a forfeiture, liability may not be fully over until the forfeiture is set aside, so ask the bondsman in writing when they consider liability terminated. Our guide to getting collateral back covers the rules.
What a co-signer should know about surrender
A co-signer often learns about a surrender after the fact. If you signed the indemnity agreement, your contract may give you a way to ask the bondsman to surrender the defendant, for example if you believe they plan to leave the state. It may also say who pays the costs. The decision still belongs to the surety, and whether the premium comes back still turns on G.S. 58-71-20.
Surrender usually reduces a co-signer's risk, because once the surety is exonerated there is no bond left to forfeit. If you are worried about a bond you guaranteed, read your agreement and talk to the bondsman before a court date is missed, not after.
This is general information, not legal advice. For advice about a specific case, talk to a licensed North Carolina attorney.
Frequently asked questions
Can a bondsman put you back in jail?
Yes. North Carolina law lets a surety arrest the defendant for the purpose of surrender and turn them over to the sheriff. The surety can also ask a judicial officer to order the arrest using a certified copy of the bond.
Do I get my premium back if my bondsman surrenders me?
Only in one situation: the surrender happened before any breach of the bond and you did none of the seven things listed in G.S. 58-71-20. Then the full premium must be returned within 72 hours. Otherwise, no refund is required.
What happens after a surrender?
The sheriff gives the surety a receipt and, after a surrender following a breach, takes the defendant before a judicial official without unnecessary delay. That official decides whether the defendant is again entitled to release and on what conditions.
Can a co-signer ask the bondsman to surrender the defendant?
A co-signer can ask, and many contracts address this, but the decision belongs to the surety. Whether a premium refund is owed still depends on G.S. 58-71-20. Read the indemnity agreement for what it says about requests to surrender.
Can I post a new bond after being surrendered?
Often, yes. After surrender a judicial official sets conditions again, and you may be able to post a bond through another surety. Expect questions about why you were surrendered.
Sources
- N.C. Gen. Stat. § 58-71-20 (Surrender of defendant by surety; premium)
- N.C. Gen. Stat. § 58-71-25 (Procedure for surrender after breach)
- N.C. Gen. Stat. § 58-71-30 (Arrest of defendant for purpose of surrender)
- N.C. Gen. Stat. § 15A-540 (Surrender of a defendant by a surety)
- N.C. Gen. Stat. § 58-71-95 (Prohibited practices)